More Pages: McDowell Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19


An excellent resource for those who want to know the truth

The road twice taken (so far)Something I particularly liked was that the journey didn't stop at the stable on Christmas Eve, but continued a full two weeks beyond--taking me back into the real world and reminding me that I cannot remain at that special place, that the stable has gifts for me to return to the everyday world. At this point, I plan to make the journey again in 2002.


Layering traditional blocks to make unique quilts.

A Very Important AnthologyM and W is an important text; it engages, as very few contemporary philosophy of mind texts have, the serious and neglected dualisms of conceptual scheme and empirical content; spontaneity and receptivity, which are, needless to say, Kantian concerns. McDowell is a proponent of conceptual content (within the realm of a 'minimal empiricism') and appeals to Kant and Wittgenstein to buttress his descriptive approach to philosophical inquiry. M and W has some brillant and evocative insights (with more than a few expensive obscurities), and some of McDowell's metaphors are splendid indeed, such as the teetering 'seesaw' and the 'sideways on picture.' Of course, it attempts to negotiate Kantian insights concerning human cognition with certain contemporary discussions on the Myth of the Given (Sellars), The Third Dogma (Davidson)and the Tribunal of Experience (Quine), and Rorty's attack on epistemology.
This anthology could offer disenchanted graduate students a reason to complete doctoral studies in philosophy. It is that rich and exciting. I am seriously nervous with glee (nerd alert!).
The most important and interesting articles here are: M. Friedman, "Exorcising the Philosophical Tradition" (previously published); R. Pippin, "Leaving Nature Behind" (on subjectivism); B. Stroud, "Sense Experience and the Grounding of Thought" (always a pleasure to read Barry); R. Brandom, "Non-Inferential Knowledge, Perceptual Experience..."; G. McCulloch, "Phenomenological Externalism" (see A. Brueckner and/or K. Falvey on this topic); H. Putnam, "McD's Mind and McD's World" (also see his Three-Fold Cord on McD and his soon to be released UW lectures from Columbia UP); C. Larmore, "Attending to Reasons."
This is my highest recommendation.


great collection of essays

Just what I was looking for....

Concise facts and debunked mythsIn this book, McDowell addresses all possible (and not-so-possible) "natural" explanations of the resurrection, and discusses them in detail, proving each one wrong. His approach of letting the facts speak for themselves rather than trying to press them into a belief system is what really impressed me.
With all the evidence presented, I can no longer deny the facts, and have accepted Jesus as my Lord and Savior. There just isn't a doubt any more.


This book is absolutely awesome!

The wake up call.

Excellent! Shows success by women who have trusted Christ.